← notes
22 November 2026

The Long and the Short of It, explained

Les Binet and Peter Field's 2013 study of IPA effectiveness cases is one of the most quoted pieces of marketing research. Here is what it found, in plain English, and what it means for your budget.

Fox illustration for the note on The Long and the Short of It

The Long and the Short of It is a study by Les Binet and Peter Field, published by the IPA in 2013, of what makes advertising pay back over time. Built on the IPA's database of proven campaigns, its main finding is that marketing works in two different ways, short-term sales activation and long-term brand building, and that companies that invest in both, with the larger share on brand building, make the most profit. It's also where the rule of thumb of about 60% brand and 40% activation comes from.

What it studied

Binet and Field used the IPA Databank, a collection of campaigns entered for the IPA's effectiveness awards, where entrants have to prove their results. Thinkbox's summary describes the wider body of analysis as "1,000 advertising campaigns from over 30 years of IPA Effectiveness data". The IPA describes the report as exploring "a growing tension that exists between short-term response activity and long-term brand-building."

What it found

These are the main findings as Thinkbox, the TV industry body that has summarised the work since 2012, sets them out.

Long-term investment pays more. "Long-term (3+ years) investment in advertising delivers double the profit of a short-term approach (less than 1 year), but investing in both delivers even higher returns."

Short-term numbers mislead. "Short and long term effects work differently which means that short term metrics, especially direct response rates, may not be a good guide to long term success."

Emotion beats reason over time. "Emotional advertising is twice as efficient as rational, and delivers twice the profit."

Reach the whole market. "Brands which target the whole market achieve 3 times as many large business effects than those that focus on existing customers." And "Tight audience targeting, whilst desirable for activation, does not help long-term success."

Spend most of it on brand building. "The largest part of an advertising budget should be invested in media with a mass reach and long-term effects," and "At least 60% should be invested in these brand-building media."

Why it mattered

It put numbers behind something many marketers felt but couldn't prove: that the campaigns which look best in the weekly report aren't the ones that build the business. The IPA's own warning is that "there is a tendency to use very short-term online metrics as primary performance measures and this has dangerous implications for long-term success."

Binet and Field went on to look at digital media in Media in Focus, produced with Google and Thinkbox, and at B2B with the LinkedIn B2B Institute, where they found the balance in B2B sits closer to 50/50 "since sales is harder."

The limits

The data comes from award entries, which are the campaigns companies were proud enough to submit. Neil Krikul of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute notes it "might not be representative," and that the authors themselves "acknowledged that this may vary by category." Thinkbox, which carries the best-known summary, is a body that promotes TV advertising, so read its claims about TV with that in mind. The findings about how marketing works are widely accepted. The exact percentages are averages, not targets.

What it means for you

This part is our advice.

Don't judge brand building on this month's leads. It's designed to pay back over years, so measure it on reach across your market and on whether more buyers think of you.

Run both, on purpose. Decide how much goes on each and label your spend by its job, so the short-term half can't quietly eat the long-term half.

Reach beyond the people already looking. The study's finding on targeting the whole market matches the Ehrenberg-Bass research on mental availability: most of your future buyers aren't in the market now, and you need them to remember you when they are.

Make people feel something. Rational messages sell to people already deciding. Emotional ones are what people remember.

Read next: Brand vs performance marketing: how to split your spend, What is mental availability? and Marketing budget as a percentage of revenue.

This note was drafted with AI and checked by Paul Dervan before it was published.

Sources

IPA, The Long and the Short of It, by Les Binet and Peter Field: ipa.co.uk. Thinkbox, summary of The Long and the Short of It, posted 6 December 2012, last updated 23 October 2026: thinkbox.tv. IPA, Media in Focus: ipa.co.uk. LinkedIn B2B Institute, The 5 Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing: business.linkedin.com. Neil Krikul, Ehrenberg-Bass Institute: marketingscience.info.

Free AI marketing course: AI Fluency for Ambitious Marketers runs one module a fortnight from 21st September.