← notes
22 November 2026

How to brief a creative agency

Most marketers think they write good briefs. Most agencies disagree. Here is what the research on briefing found, what a good brief needs, and how to brief so the work comes back right first time.

Fox illustration for the note on briefing a creative agency

A good creative brief tells the agency what business problem you're trying to solve, who you need to reach, the one thing you want them to take away, and how you'll judge the work. Most briefs don't. In the largest study of briefing we know of, "80% of marketers consider themselves good at writing briefs; only 10% of agencies agree with that." The gap costs money, time and better work.

What the research found

The BetterBriefs Project surveyed over 1,700 people in marketing and agencies across 70 countries, and presented the results at the IPA's EffWorks conference. Beyond the 80% against 10% gap, it found "Only 5% of agencies are clear on the strategic direction in briefs," and "60% of marketers use the creative process to clarify their own strategy." In other words, many briefs go out before the marketer has decided what they want, and the agency's work becomes the way they find out. The study estimates that "Up to 33% of marketing budgets is wasted due to poor briefs and misdirected work."

A follow-up study in 2025, run with the IPA and the World Federation of Advertisers, surveyed 1,034 people across 54 countries. It found "it typically takes 5 rounds of creative development to get to a signed-off idea (up from 3 rounds as recorded in IPA research in the UK in 2007)." Only "23% of agencies and even fewer (15%) marketers agree that briefs are always used by their organisations when evaluating ideas," and "Only 10% of all respondents agree that ideas are always evaluated against clearly defined criteria."

So the brief is often weak going in, and often ignored when the work comes back.

What a good brief contains

The research tells you briefs are a problem. It doesn't hand you a template, so this part is our advice, from writing and receiving a lot of them.

Start with the business problem, not the deliverable. "We need a video" isn't a brief. "Sales in Munster are flat because buyers there don't think of us for commercial jobs" is. The agency may find a better answer than a video.

Say who you need to reach, and what they think and do now. Real people, described plainly: their situation, what they believe about you or your category, and what they do instead of buying from you.

Give one message. The single thing you want them to remember or believe after seeing the work. If you can't get it down to one sentence, the strategy isn't finished yet, and the BetterBriefs finding says that's the most common problem.

Say how you'll judge it. What would success look like in numbers and in what people say? Agree that before the work is made, so the work can be judged against it rather than against taste in the room.

Add the practical parts. Budget, timing, the channels it has to work in, and the things it must include, like legal lines, brand assets or a product. Keep the list of must-haves short. Every one you add takes freedom away from the work.

Keep it short. A page or two. A long brief usually means the decisions haven't been made.

How to brief, not just what to write

Brief in person, or at least on a call, and let them question it. The conversation is where a weak brief gets found out, and that's much cheaper than finding out in round four.

Use the brief when the work comes back. Judge every idea against the problem, audience, message and measures you wrote down. The IPA's Laurence Green calls for "briefs as lodestars", and the 2025 study shows most organisations don't use them that way.

Give clear feedback. Only "30% of agencies and around half (52%) of marketers agree that clients/they provide clear and constructive feedback." Say what's working, what isn't and why, against the brief. "I'll know it when I see it" costs rounds.

Read next: Category entry points, with examples, The Long and the Short of It, explained and Brand vs performance marketing: how to split your spend.

This note was drafted with AI and checked by Paul Dervan before it was published.

Sources

The BetterBriefs Project, global report, presented at IPA EffWorks: betterbriefs.com. IPA, on the BetterIdeas Project, 4 March 2025: ipa.co.uk.

Free AI marketing course: AI Fluency for Ambitious Marketers runs one module a fortnight from 21st September.